Files
boocode/openspec/changes/v1.13.18-codecontext-file-path/proposal.md
indifferentketchup 1a889dcde3 v1.13.18-codecontext-file-path: resolve file_path against project root in codecontext wrappers
Four codecontext sidecar wrappers — get_file_analysis (required
file_path), get_symbol_info, get_dependencies, and get_semantic_neighborhoods
(optional) — forwarded file_path to the HTTP sidecar unchanged. The
sidecar's internal file index is keyed on absolute paths, so any
relative path from the model returned "File not found in graph".
Three back-to-back failures observed in one chat on 2026-05-22
17:56 UTC, ~48 s of wasted tool budget.

## Resolver

Add resolveProjectPath(projectRoot, rawPath) in codecontext_client.ts:
trim check → absolute/relative branch (both go through resolve() so
dot-segments normalise) → realpath with ENOENT fallthrough → escape
check using the realpathed value. Error shape mirrors the existing
target_dir escape error byte-for-byte; only the field name differs.

Wired into callCodecontext at the args-spread site, guarded on
file_path presence + non-empty. All four wrappers benefit from one
call site; wrappers without file_path (overview, framework, watch,
search) are unaffected.

## Schema trim

.trim() added to all four file_path Zod schemas:

  get_file_analysis:                  z.string().trim().min(1)
  get_symbol_info:                    z.string().trim().optional()
  get_dependencies:                   z.string().trim().optional()
  get_semantic_neighborhoods:         z.string().trim().optional()

Absorbs trailing newlines / whitespace from model output before the
resolver sees the value.

## Adversarial review fixes

Adversarial pass surfaced two P2 findings:

1. Absolute path with `..` resolving outside the project root (e.g.
   `<projectRoot>/../etc/passwd`) that ENOENTs at realpath would slip
   through the literal prefix-check: the raw string starts with
   `<projectRoot>/`. Fix: resolve() the absolute branch's candidate
   too, so dot-segments normalise before the prefix check.

2. No symlink-escape test coverage. Realpath's stated purpose
   (catching in-project symlinks pointing outside the project) was
   never tested. Added: create a tmpdir outside projectRoot,
   symlink projectRoot/evil-link → outside file, assert rejection.

## Tests

codecontext_client.test.ts: 19 tests (10 baseline + 9 new file_path
resolution cases). Cases cover: relative→absolute, absolute-inside,
relative-escape, absolute-outside, ENOENT-fallthrough, empty-string,
wrapper-without-file_path, absolute-with-`..`-ENOENT,
symlink-leaving-root.

codecontext_tools.test.ts: one assertion updated to expect the
resolved-absolute file_path on the wire (previously asserted the raw
relative path passed through, which is exactly the bug being fixed).

Full suite: 301 passed, 7 skipped.

## Affected / unaffected

- get_codebase_overview, get_framework_analysis, watch_changes,
  search_symbols: no file_path arg → resolver guard skips them. No
  behavior change.
- get_semantic_neighborhoods IS in SYNTHESIS_TOOLS — previously-failing
  relative-path calls will now successfully synthesize. Desirable, not
  a regression.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-05-22 21:54:16 +00:00

37 lines
2.2 KiB
Markdown

# v1.13.18 — codecontext file_path resolver
Fixes a silent failure that caused all four `file_path`-taking codecontext wrappers to return "file not found" whenever the model passed a relative path.
## Why
BooCode's codecontext sidecar (`codecontext_client.ts`) already realpath-resolves `target_dir` before forwarding it to the HTTP shim. It did not do the same for `file_path`. The sidecar's internal file index is keyed on absolute paths, so any relative path from the model produced a JSON error response:
```
{"error":"file not found: apps/server/src/services/inference/turn.ts","result":null}
```
This was observed repeatedly in the 2026-05-22 docker logs (17:56 UTC window) — the model passed relative paths on every `get_file_analysis` tool call and received no useful output, burning tool budget on dead calls.
## Scope
Four wrappers take a `file_path` argument:
- `tools/codecontext/get_file_analysis.ts``file_path` required
- `tools/codecontext/get_symbol_info.ts``file_path` optional
- `tools/codecontext/get_dependencies.ts``file_path` optional
- `tools/codecontext/get_semantic_neighborhoods.ts``file_path` optional
Fix lands in one place: `callCodecontext` in `codecontext_client.ts`. A new `resolveProjectPath` helper is inserted at the args-spread site and invoked whenever `file_path` is present and non-empty. All four wrappers benefit automatically; no per-wrapper edits required.
Zod `.trim()` is added to all four `file_path` schema entries so that whitespace-padded paths from the model are cleaned before they reach the resolver.
## Decision: single resolver over per-wrapper edits
Four wrappers, one shared code path. Per-wrapper edits would require four edits and make it easy to miss one. The `callCodecontext` shim already owns `target_dir` validation; `file_path` validation belongs there too for symmetry.
## Non-goals
- No changes to the `target_dir` resolver — it already works correctly.
- No extension to wrappers that do not take `file_path` (`get_codebase_overview`, `get_framework_analysis`, `search_symbols`, `watch_changes`).
- No fix for the unrelated RPC errors and Go map-race warnings visible in the codecontext sidecar logs — those are upstream bugs.