enqueueMove called channel.setParent(categoryId, { lockPermissions: true }).
discord.js's default for setParent is also true. With lockPermissions: true,
Discord re-syncs the channel's permission overwrites to match the new
parent category — so the explicit per-user allows set at ticket creation
(creator) and via /add (extra members) got wiped on every escalate,
de-escalate, and /move. The creator literally lost View Channel on their
own ticket the moment staff hit Escalate.
Flip to lockPermissions: false so the existing channel-level overwrites
are preserved across the parent change. Inheritance still applies for
anything the channel doesn't override — and the deny-@everyone /
role-allow set at creation continues to gate access correctly.
Affects every caller of enqueueMove:
- handlers/commands/escalation.js runEscalation
- handlers/commands/escalation.js runDeescalation
- handlers/commands/index.js handleMove (/move)
Two paired logWarn calls used to post to DEBUGGING_CHANNEL_ID every time
the RENAMER_BOT secondary token hit Discord's per-channel rename quota:
Warning: renamer — "429 rename channel=… retry_after=…"
Warning: renameQueue — "secondary-bot 429; falling back to primary…"
Both fire on the recoverable path: the channelQueue immediately falls
back to the primary discord.js client, and that client's REST handler
transparently waits out the retry_after and retries — the rename lands
without operator action. Posting these to the debug channel was pure
noise; staff were reading them as failures when nothing had failed.
Demoted both to console.warn so they still appear in `docker logs
broccolini` for diagnostic purposes but no longer post to Discord.
Kept untouched:
- utils/renamer.js:64 — 401/403 logWarn on secondary-bot auth/permission
errors (real config problems; the operator does need to know).
- services/channelQueue.js next.catch logError for status 401/403/429 —
only fires when the fallback itself also failed (rare and worth a
debug-channel post).
QUAL-004 handlers/messages.js — DM-on-customer-reply now reads
guild.members.cache.get(claimerId) first and only falls back to
guild.members.fetch on cache miss. Avoids a REST round-trip per non-staff
reply on busy tickets. GuildMembers intent already keeps the cache warm.
QUAL-005 handlers/buttons.js (runFinalClose) + handlers/commands/close.js
(finalizeForceClose) — close paths now $unset welcomeMessageId alongside
the status: 'closed' write. Stops a stale message-ID from carrying into a
future reopen on the same Gmail thread, where escalation's "edit welcome
buttons" path would silently fail trying to fetch a message in a deleted
channel.
QUAL-007 services/configPersistence.js — writeEnvFile mismatch error now
includes the missing/extra key sets, not just count vs count. Saves the
operator from guessing which key vanished after a partial write.
QUAL-008 utils.js stripEmailQuotes — replaced order-dependent first-match
loop with an earliest-match-across-all-markers scan. The previous code
could truncate at a late "_____" signature underline even when an earlier
"On X wrote:" reply header was the real cutoff. New test in
tests/utils.test.js exercises the dual-marker case.
QUAL-010 broccolini-discord.js — moved `let httpServer / internalServer /
appReady` declarations from after the ready handler to before it. Same
runtime behavior (module-load completes before ready fires asynchronously),
but the read order now matches the assignment order.
SEC-002 routes/internalApi.js — POST /restart now goes through a tighter
2/min limiter on top of the shared 10/min internalLimiter. Defense in
depth in case INTERNAL_API_SECRET ever leaks; an attacker with the secret
can no longer crash-loop the container.
Skipped: QUAL-009 (re-checked the regex; ^\s*\n* → \n is already
idempotent — the audit finding was incorrect).
vitest run: 88/88 (one new test for QUAL-008).
[SEC-004] services/staffThread.js — addRoleMembersToThread previously called
the unscoped guild.members.fetch() on every ticket creation, chunking every
member of the guild. With STAFF_THREAD_AUTO_ADD_ROLE on and a 50-member
staff role, the 300ms-per-add loop also blocked ticket creation for ~15s.
- Read role.members directly (computed from guild.members.cache, kept in
sync via the GuildMembers gateway intent set on the client). Skip the
explicit unscoped fetch in the hot path.
- Cache-cold fallback: one scoped guild.members.fetch({ withPresences:
false }) — irrelevant presence sync stays off the wire.
- createStaffThread no longer awaits the add-loop. Wraps the call in
setImmediate(...) so ticket creation returns immediately while the
rate-limited add-loop runs in the background.
[SEC-005] services/debugLog.js — stacks/messages posted to the debug
channel could leak customer email addresses (interpolated through ticket
errors) and Discord member/channel IDs. Add a redactPII helper applied to
both logError's message + stack and logWarn's body:
- Email regex /[\w.+-]+@[\w.-]+\.\w+/g → [EMAIL_REDACTED]
- Discord snowflake /\b\d{18,20}\b/g → [ID_REDACTED]
interaction.user.tag in the User: line is intentionally not redacted —
it's needed for triage and is not PII (Discord usernames are public).
QUAL-006 store ticket.creatorId on creation; legacy split-pop returned the
message ID for discord-msg-* tickets, breaking transcript DM, close
log, and channel rename for context-menu-created tickets. Adds the
field to the Ticket schema and writes a one-shot backfill script
(scripts/backfill-creatorId.js, dry-run by default).
QUEUE-001 add enqueueOverwrite + enqueueTopic to services/channelQueue.js
(chain on renameChains alongside enqueueMove). Migrate handleAdd /
handleRemove / handleMove / handleTopic so permissionOverwrites,
setParent, and setTopic no longer race pending renames or sends.
handleMove now uses the existing enqueueMove. Initial overwrites in
handleTicketModal stay inline; channel doesn't exist yet so no race.
DISCORD-001 replace ephemeral: true with flags: MessageFlags.Ephemeral across
broccolini-discord.js, handlers/sharedHelpers.js, handlers/buttons.js,
handlers/commands.js. runDeferred opts now take { flags } directly.
SEC-003 /gmailpoll min interval is 30s. Drop the 5s/10s slash-command
choices and clamp Math.max(30000, ms) in handleGmailPoll for
defense in depth.
QUAL-001 upgrade silent .catch(() => {}) on the lastActivity updateOne in
handlers/messages.js to log via logError, so transient Mongo errors
surface in the debug channel instead of disappearing.
QUAL-002 drop await from logError/logWarn calls in services/staffThread.js
and services/pinMessage.js — fire-and-forget per CLAUDE.md hard rule.
QUAL-003 wrap stray setTimeouts (handleConfirmCloseRequest force-close timer,
runFinalClose channel-delete + overflow-cleanup, checkAutoClose
delete-after-email) in trackTimeout via lazy require so they clear
on shutdown.
- Rename CONFIG.TRANSCRIPT_CHAN -> CONFIG.TRANSCRIPT_CHANNEL_ID and
CONFIG.LOG_CHAN -> CONFIG.LOGGING_CHANNEL_ID across 9 callsites so
CONFIG keys match their .env names — no more "grep .env, find nothing"
for new readers
- Replace handlers/commands.js#hasStaffRole with utils.js#isStaff
(was a verbatim copy)
- Delete utils.js#enforceEmbedLimit and its 2 callsites; both inputs are
bounded well under the 6000-char Discord embed cap, so the trim was
defensive code that never fired
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Remove no-op log stubs (logGmail, logAutomation, logSecurity, logSystem)
and ~17 callsites; dead counters in tickets.js and gmail-poll.js go too
- Dedup three near-identical Gmail send paths into sendThreadedEmail helper
- Drop dead Mongoose fields: broccoliniTicketId, lastSyncedBroccoliniArticleId,
renameCount, renameWindowStart, reminderSent, staffChannelId,
unclaimedRemindersSent, lastMessageAuthorIsStaff
- Drop dead config fields and their .env.example entries
- Inline api/botClient.js (3-line wrapper, 2 callers)
- Trim unused exports across utils.js, tickets.js, configSchema.js, debugLog.js
- Fix handlers/messages.js to use isStaff() — old partial check ignored
ADDITIONAL_STAFF_ROLES, so those members were treated as customers
- Drop unused deps p-queue + dotenv-expand; move mongodb to devDependencies
Net: -583 LOC source + -57 LOC lockfile. All 23 modules load clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- secondary rename-bot token was set as RENAME_TOKEN in .env but utils/renamer.js reads RENAMER_BOT; silently no-op'd every rename (host .env renamed separately)
- services/tickets.js canRename gutted to an always-ok shim; Mongo 2/10min per-channel gate is redundant since renames flow through RENAMER_BOT's own bucket. Ticket.renameCount / renameWindowStart remain as orphan fields (no migration)
- handlers/buttons.js + commands.js: drop the four "Channel renamed too quickly" else-branches and the rename-countdown label suffix; replace .catch(() => {}) with .catch(err => logError('rename', err)...)
- services/channelQueue.js: executeRename falls back to channel.setName(currentName) when renamer throws err.fallback === true (401/403/429); classifies non-fallback errors as renameQueue:token/permission (401/403) or renameQueue:secondary-bot ratelimited (429)
- utils/renamer.js: on 401/403 throw err.fallback=true immediately; on 429 respect retry_after up to 2000ms then throw err.fallback=true
- docs: align CLAUDE.md, docs/api/DISCORD_API_VALIDATION.md, docs/architecture/CRITICAL_FILES_AND_HOW_IT_WORKS.md
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
